[Dang, he was definitely going to ask if she was Coraline who probably wasn't on the boat? but maybe was idk and really piss her off. It's not like she ever actually managed to topple him overboard...]

Theeeen it's gotta be... Contrary Mary. ["Contrary" to first impressions, that is, because she's a huge monster! But she's also just a cute lil' kid that Pickles only vaaaaguely remembers getting stabbed by!] That's soooome co-inky-dink you got yerself the only kid body on this rig so far!